Call Us Today!(740) 545-6002 

Best Selling Cheeses

Since 1928, we have been making and selling award-winning cheese. Our cheese is great for a cheese tray, on a sandwich, or on its own! 

This collection includes some of our best-selling cheeses, and if you've never had our cheeses before, we recommend you start here with your first order.

mild swiss cheese

Mild Swiss Cheese

from $6.35
from $6.35
Colby Cheese

Colby Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
pepper jack cheese

Pepper Jack Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
marble cheese

Marble Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
lacey baby swiss cheese

Lacey Baby Swiss Cheese

from $6.35
from $6.35
emmentaler old world swiss cheese

Emmentaler Old World Swiss Cheese

$6.35
$6.35
smoked swiss cheese

Smoked Swiss Cheese

$6.99
$6.99
super hot jumping jack cheese

Super Hot Jumping Jack Cheese

from $6.35
from $6.35
lacey style cheese

Lacey Style Cheese

$6.35
$6.35
baby swiss cheese

Baby Swiss Cheese

$6.35
$6.35
muenster cheese

Muenster Cheese

$5.95
$5.95
gouda cheese

Gouda Cheese

from $6.35
from $6.35
salsa jack

Salsa Jack Cheese

$6.35
$6.35
colby swiss swirl cheese

Colby Swiss Swirl Cheese

$6.35
$6.35
smoked gouda

Smoked Gouda Cheese

$6.99
$6.99
ohio pure maple syrup

Ohio Pure Maple Syrup

$15.00
$15.00
aged-swiss-cheese

Aged Swiss Cheese

$6.70
$6.70
farmers cheese

Farmers Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
bacon cheese

Bacon Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
horseradish cheese

Horseradish Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
jalapeno cheese hot pepper

Jalapeno Cheese (Hot Pepper)

from $5.95
from $5.95
onion processed cheese

Onion Processed Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
Pearl Valley Pepperoni Processed Cheese

Pepperoni Processed Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
garlic cheese

Garlic Cheese

from $5.95
from $5.95
extra sharp white cheddar cheese

Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese

$11.30
$11.30
havarti cheese

Havarti Cheese

$7.75
$7.75
Mozzarella Cheese

Mozzarella Cheese

$5.95
$5.95
Pearl Valley Provolone Cheese

Provolone Cheese

$5.95
$5.95
american sliced cheese

American Sliced Cheese

from $6.90
from $6.90
Pearl Valley Cheese Chipotle Pepper Jack

Chipotle Pepper Jack

from $5.95
from $5.95