Call Us Today! (740) 545-6002
Sign in
or
Create an Account
Search
Cart
0
Search
Home
Shop Online
Gift Boxes with FREE SHIPPING
Swiss Cheese Varieties
Colby, Marble, and Cheddar
Flavored Cheeses
Other Favorite Cheeses
Meats
Cheese Trays
Apparel
About Us
History
Commitment to Quality
Awards
Environmental Sustainability
Employment
Amish Country Butter
The Cheesemaking Process
Shipping Information
Manufacturing
Fundraisers
Visit Us
Hours and Directions
In Store Specials
Contact Us
Producers Log In
Recipes
What's New
Videos
Articles
Sign in
Create an Account
Menu
Cart
0
Home
›
Gift Boxes - FREE SHIPPING!
›
sharp colored cheddar
Gift Boxes - FREE SHIPPING!
Please note shipping is included in all of our gift box prices.
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Filters
Brunch Box
$47
00
Natural Cheese Bonanza
$47
00
Party Cheese Package
$43
00
Pearl Valley Jackpot
$75
00
